Case Histories
by Kate Atkinson
A private investigator in Edinburgh looks into three old family mysteries, and a novel about loss, motherhood and how people live on after the worst happens.
Good for
About the book
Private investigator Jackson Brodie takes on three separate cases in Edinburgh: a missing child, a violent attack on a young woman, and a mother's desperate act. The cases reach back thirty years, and as he digs, links appear between them.
What readers keep from this book
-
Grief doesn't end, it carries on
Several passages treat loss as something with no neat close. One father holds on to the pain because it keeps his daughter present, and fears that healing would let her fade. Simply going on living after the worst has happened is shown as quiet courage.
-
Parenting is often duty without feeling
The mothers in these pages are tired, resentful and unsure. One admits she is a poor mother but is too worn out even to feel guilty, and another gives only duty to the children she doesn't favor. Love between parent and child runs one way and owes nothing back.
-
Life is messier than the stories we read
A character blames novels for promising endings when real life just keeps going. Others picture romantic landscapes or a perfect country home that real life never matches. Even the detective hears himself sound like a cliché and winces.
Who it is for
Readers who like a mystery that cares more about its people's inner lives than about the puzzle, and who enjoy dry humor beside real sadness. Pass if you want a fast, tidy whodunit, or if stories about harm to children and mothers in distress are hard for you.
If you liked this
Something wrong on this page? Write to hello@usebecoming.com and we will fix it.