Becoming
Cover of Plain Truth

Plain Truth

by Jodi Picoult

A Philadelphia defense lawyer takes on an unwilling Amish teenager accused of killing her newborn, and finds her own life questioned along the way.

About the book

Plain Truth is a legal drama set in an Amish community in Pennsylvania, where a dead newborn is found in a barn and the baby's young, unmarried mother is arrested. Ellie Hathaway, a city defense attorney, leaves her career behind and chooses to defend her. The case asks what happened, and what justice means to people who live by different rules.

What readers keep from this book

  1. Communities judge in different ways

    The novel sets two ideas of judgment side by side. In the outside world, blame is a way to cast someone out, while the Amish treat a charge of wrongdoing as a path back, a chance to make amends and rejoin the group. Ellie has to learn this before she can understand her client.

  2. Being surrounded is not being connected

    The book returns to loneliness in crowded, wired places. Characters note that people can reach each other instantly and still feel alone. Ellie's habit of leaving before others can leave her is shown as the same kind of isolation, a private one.

  3. Putting yourself first has a price

    Katie's story turns on a young woman raised to put the group above herself, who for once acts on her own wants. The novel treats this as the real sin in her eyes, more than the act itself. It also asks whether memory can be trusted when the truth hurts, and whether forgetting is a way of coping.

Who it is for

Readers who like courtroom mysteries with a family drama at the center, and who enjoy learning about a way of life far from their own. It suits someone who wants a story about faith, guilt and fear of loss. Those who want a fast, purely procedural legal thriller may find the personal threads slow it down.

If you liked this

Something wrong on this page? Write to hello@usebecoming.com and we will fix it.