Becoming
Cover of The American Way of Killing

The American Way of Killing

by Malcolm Gladwell

Gladwell asks why the US has far more killings than other rich countries, and works toward an answer through stories about guns, police, prisons and hospitals.

Good for

About the book

This book takes on a single question: why does the wealthiest country suffer homicide on a scale usually seen in much poorer ones? Gladwell looks for answers in a series of separate stories rather than one long argument, moving across several American places.

What readers keep from this book

  1. The problem is violence, not crime

    Gladwell argues that Americans misread what they are facing. Much killing, he says, is young men in heated arguments, not careful criminal planning. The book keeps pushing the reader away from the picture of murder drawn by mystery shows.

  2. The country has too few police

    The book makes the case that the US is underpoliced, not overpoliced. With thin police coverage, a force tends to rely on dramatic shows of strength. Countries with strong police capacity see very few civilians die in encounters with officers.

  3. Certainty deters more than harsh sentences

    Gladwell contrasts two ways of discouraging crime. Europe leans on the near-certainty of being caught, while the US leans on long sentences. The book uses this contrast to explain why the two systems look so different.

Who it is for

Readers who want a story-driven look at American gun violence and are willing to have common assumptions challenged will get the most from it. Those who want a policy manual or a single settled answer may find its narrative approach too loose.

If you liked this

Something wrong on this page? Write to hello@usebecoming.com and we will fix it.