Becoming
Cover of The Ask and the Answer

The Ask and the Answer

by Patrick Ness

A guide to The Ask and the Answer by Patrick Ness, a novel about Todd and Viola living under a tyrant's rule, and the ideas readers keep from it.

About the book

This is the second book in the Chaos Walking trilogy. Todd and Viola are split up after falling into the hands of Mayor Prentiss, and Todd is locked up and made to learn the Mayor's rules while a resistance called the Answer works in the shadows.

What readers keep from this book

  1. Love can make you hard to control

    One passage turns the usual warning around. Caring deeply about something is described as a strength, because people who love fiercely are the ones a tyrant cannot easily bend. Todd and Viola's bond is what keeps each of them going when everything else is taken.

  2. We are what we choose

    The book keeps returning to the idea that a person is made of their choices, including the ones forced on them. Todd and Viola both do hard and ugly things, and the story asks what they do next, not whether they ever fall.

  3. Forgiveness is a choice you repeat

    Characters who have hurt each other ask to be forgiven, and the answer is given plainly and more than once. Falling is treated as normal, and getting back up and forgiving again is what counts. Even a dying enemy begs for it.

Who it is for

Readers who finished the first Chaos Walking book and want to see Todd and Viola tested under a harsh regime. It suits anyone who likes stories about resistance, loyalty and hard moral choices. Readers who want a gentle story should pass, as the violence and cruelty here are heavy.

If you liked this

Something wrong on this page? Write to hello@usebecoming.com and we will fix it.